Existing code review tools for Java

Sara Verdi
Sara Verdi
Graphite software engineer

In software development, code review isn't just a routine task—it's an important practice that ensures your code meets the highest standards, particularly for your Java projects. As they grow in complexity, maintaining quality and adhering to best practices becomes increasingly challenging. In this guide, we’ll look into the landscape of code review tools designed specifically for Java and examine their key features and benefits. You'll learn how these tools can streamline your workflow and help maintain best coding practices in your projects.

For Java projects, the code review process is task you shouldn't skip due to the language's complexity. Code reviews assist with helping maintain consistency and catching errors early in the development cycle reduces the chances of bugs in production. Here are some specific tools that can help you conduct code reviews on code written in Java:

GitHub is one of the most widely used platforms for code hosting and collaboration. It also includes robust code review features that integrate seamlessly with Java projects.

Features:

  • Pull requests: Developers can submit code changes through pull requests, allowing others to review and discuss the changes before merging.
  • Inline comments: Reviewers can leave comments on specific lines of code, facilitating targeted discussions about code quality and best practices.
  • Status checks: Automated checks can be configured to enforce best practices, such as ensuring that tests pass before merging.

Bitbucket, part of the Atlassian tooling, offers similar features to GitHub, especially tailored for teams using JIRA and Confluence for project management.

Features:

  • Code insights: Provides automated insights based on static code analysis, helping enforce best practices.
  • Pull request approvals: Teams can require a certain number of approvals before merging code changes.
  • Branch permissions: Control who can merge changes, helping to maintain code quality.

GitLab is an integrated platform that offers version control, CI/CD, and code review features.

Features:

  • Merge requests: Similar to pull requests, merge requests in GitLab facilitate code reviews.
  • Code quality reports: Integrated code quality checks help teams enforce best practices by identifying issues during the merge request process.
  • Review apps: Automatically deploys changes to a temporary environment for testing, allowing reviewers to see the impact of changes in real-time.

Graphite Automations is a powerful tool that can enhance the code review process in Java development. It accelerates code reviews by automating various tasks and providing valuable insights.

Key features:

  • Automated rules: Graphite allows you to define automation rules based on file patterns, such as matching PRs that contain changes to .java files. This makes it easy to create targeted rules for specific areas of your Java codebase, like automatically notifying the front-end team when changes are made to the API layer.
  • In-line comments: Graphite's Automations can be used to automatically leave comments on pull requests, such as providing guidance or reminders for developers. For example, you could have a rule that leaves a comment on any PR touching the database access layer, reminding the author to ensure proper connection pooling and error handling.

Crucible is a dedicated code review tool by Atlassian that integrates with various version control systems.

Features:

  • Flexible review workflows: Customizable workflows allow teams to define their review processes.
  • Commenting and discussion: Inline commenting facilitates detailed discussions about specific code changes.
  • Reporting: Provides insights into the review process, helping teams analyze the effectiveness of their code reviews.

Choosing the right code review tools for Java is important for both maintaining code quality and creating a collaborative development culture. Platforms like GitHub, Bitbucket, GitLab, Graphite, and Crucible offer an array of features designed to accelerate the review process and elevate your code quality. Embracing these tools and best practices will not only enhance your projects but also keep your developers productive and happy.

Git inspired
Graphite's CLI and VS Code extension make working with Git effortless.
Learn more

Graphite
Git stacked on GitHub

Stacked pull requests are easier to read, easier to write, and easier to manage.
Teams that stack ship better software, faster.

Or install our CLI.
Product Screenshot 1
Product Screenshot 2