Read Anthropic’s case study about Graphite Reviewer

What is defect testing?

Sara Verdi
Sara Verdi
Graphite software engineer
Try Graphite

Defect testing, also known as bug testing or software testing, is the process of identifying and resolving coding defects in software testing. This practice improves both the quality and reliability of software applications. During defect testing, testers simulate various environments and use cases to uncover any issues that could impair the functionality, performance, or security of the software product.

A "defect" in software testing refers to any error or bug in the source code that causes the software to behave unexpectedly or incorrectly. Defects can range from minor issues that slightly affect usability to major bugs that can cause software to crash or result in data loss. Identifying these defects early in the development process is essential for maintaining the integrity and efficiency of the software.

  • Syntax errors: Mistakes in the code that prevent the program from running.
  • Logic errors: Flaws in the decision-making process of the application, leading to incorrect actions or results.
  • Runtime errors: Errors that occur during the execution of the software, often under specific conditions not tested during development.

Defect testing involves several stages, each designed to identify and fix different types of issues in the software. Here’s a typical workflow:

  1. Test planning: Defining the scope and objectives of the testing activities.
  2. Test design: Creating test cases that cover all aspects of the software’s functionality.
  3. Test execution: Running the tests to identify defects in the software.
  4. Defect logging: Documenting the identified defects for further analysis.
  5. Defect fixing: Addressing the logged defects by correcting the code.
  6. Regression testing: Re-testing the software to ensure that the fixes haven't introduced new defects.

Consider a scenario where a software application needs to calculate the monthly expenses based on daily inputs. If the calculation gives incorrect totals, this would be identified as a defect during testing. Testers would create test cases to simulate various inputs and verify whether the output matches the expected totals. Any discrepancy would be logged as a defect for developers to fix.

Graphite Insights is a valuable tool for teams aiming to improve engineering efficiency through detailed, data-driven insights.

Here's how Graphite Insights helps elevate engineering efficiency:

  • Improving response times: By tracking how long it takes for reviews to start and complete, teams can set benchmarks and goals to improve these times. Faster review times can lead to quicker defect detection and resolution, keeping projects on schedule.

  • Assessing review effectiveness: The number of review cycles until merge provides insight into how effective the review process is. Multiple cycles may suggest that defects are not being caught early enough, or that the submitted code often requires significant revisions. This can prompt a review of the review strategies and possibly lead to changes in how code is written and tested before it reaches the review phase.

  • Quality control: Trends in metrics collected by Graphite Insights can inform teams whether changes in the development process are improving code quality or not. For instance, if the number of review cycles decreases over time without compromising other aspects of development, it could indicate that initial code submissions are of higher quality.

  • Predictive insights: Over time, accumulating data on review times and cycles can help predict future project timelines and potential bottlenecks, allowing for better planning and resource allocation.

Graphite Insights also facilitates transparency and collaboration among team members by allowing them to monitor their progress and the quality of their contributions to the project. By integrating Graphite Insights into the defect testing process, teams can leverage historical data and real-time feedback to make informed decisions and enhance software quality continuously.

Defect testing is a key component of software development that ensures the delivery of high-quality products. By understanding what defects can occur and how to effectively test and fix them, teams can prevent costly errors and enhance user satisfaction. Tools like Graphite Insights play a role in this process by providing the metrics and insights needed to manage and optimize software testing efforts effectively.

Git inspired
Graphite's CLI and VS Code extension make working with Git effortless.
Learn more

Built for the world's fastest engineering teams, now available for everyone